Otterly.AI vs Rankscale vs Airefs vs Nimt.ai: Budget AI Trackers Compared on a 30-Prompt Workload (2026)

No independent head-to-head of these four budget AI visibility trackers exists yet. Here is a 30-prompt cost and coverage comparison built from published pricing, plus a protocol to run the same test yourself.

Key takeaways

  • I could not find an independent test that ran Otterly.AI, Rankscale, Airefs and Nimt.ai on identical prompts, so this guide does not invent results. It compares what each vendor publishes for a 30-prompt workload and gives you a protocol to run the real test.
  • On published numbers, Airefs has the lowest cost per answer (about $0.0098 on yearly billing). Rankscale is close behind on its mid plan. Otterly is cheap to enter but caps you at 15 prompts on the $29 plan.
  • Nimt.ai at $89/mo is not really a budget tool, but it bundles an agent, daily tracking and 230 countries.
  • Engine overlap is smaller than it looks. Only ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Copilot appear on every plan's engine list, so a fair test uses those three.
  • Pricing in this category changes constantly and third-party snapshots disagree. Confirm every number on the vendor's own page before paying.

Why a same-prompts comparison is hard

I would love to give you a table of visibility scores: the same 30 prompts, four tools, and who found your brand most often. That test hasn't been published anywhere I could find. The comparison pages on this topic (Fame, Rank Prompt, Track My Visibility) compare pricing and engine lists, not measured output on a shared prompt set.

So here is what I can do honestly. First, line up the published limits against a concrete 30-prompt workload. Second, flag where the sources conflict. Third, lay out a test design that makes the four tools comparable, so the numbers you get are yours and not marketing.

The four tools differ in what they count. Otterly sells prompts. Rankscale sells credits that convert to answers. Airefs sells monthly AI answers, where one answer is one question asked once to one AI tool. Nimt sells credits, with a cap of 72 prompts a day on its Flex plan. Those units are not comparable until you convert them.

The 30-prompt workload

Take a realistic small-brand setup: 30 prompts, tracked on 4 engines, checked daily. That is 30 x 4 x 30 = 3,600 AI answers a month. Check weekly instead and it is about 480 answers a month (30 x 4 x 4).

Everything below is calculated from that workload.

Published pricing side by side

ToolEntry pricePrompt or volume limitEnginesFits 30 prompts?
Otterly.AI$29/mo (15 prompts); $189/mo (100 prompts)Prompt-basedChatGPT, AI Overviews, Perplexity, Copilot fixed; others are add-onsNot on the 15-prompt plan
Rankscale$17/mo, yearly only (some sources say $20); $84/mo mid plan120 credits, up to 480 answers; mid plan up to 4,80017+ on every planWeekly on entry; daily on the mid plan
Airefs$49/mo billed yearly, $59 monthly5,000 answers/mo, then $8 per 1,000ChatGPT, AI Overviews, Gemini, Copilot; Claude is an add-on; Perplexity not listedYes, 3,600 within 5,000
Nimt.ai$89/mo (Flex)10,000 credits, up to 72 promptsChatGPT, ChatGPT Search, Bing AI Mode, AI Mode, AI Overviews, Gemini, ClaudeYes, per-check credit cost unpublished

Sources: Fame's November 2026 comparison for Otterly and Rankscale, Airefs and Nimt pricing pages, Tonaily for Otterly's answer math. I did not verify Otterly's or Rankscale's live pages myself.

Cost per answer, normalised

Sticker price misleads here. Rank Prompt's research put the real unit cost across this category at roughly $10 to $109 per 1,000 AI responses, an 11x spread. Here is the same math for these four:

PlanAnswers per monthCost per answer
Airefs (yearly, $49)5,000 includedabout $0.0098
Airefs (monthly, $59)5,000 includedabout $0.0118
Rankscale mid ($84)up to 4,800about $0.0175
Rankscale entry ($17, yearly)up to 480about $0.035
Otterly Lite ($29)1,800 (15 prompts x 4 engines x 30 days)about $0.016
Otterly $189 tierabout 12,000 (100 x 4 x 30, my math)about $0.016
Nimt Flex ($89)unpublishedcannot be calculated

Two cautions. The Airefs figure matches the vendor's own claim ($0.0098), and the same claim says Peec costs $0.0205 and Profound $0.0443, which is vendor-supplied and unaudited. And Rankscale's $0.035 only holds if you really use all 480 answers; credits are not always the same as answers.

Otterly's cost per answer looks fine, but its 15-prompt cap is the real constraint. To track 30 prompts you would need a tier between $29 and $189, and I did not find that tier's price in my sources.

Tool by tool

Otterly.AI

Favicon of Otterly.AI

Otterly.AI

Affordable AI visibility tracking tool
View more
Screenshot of Otterly.AI website

Otterly is the one most independent roundups name first. Fame's table lists it as the best low-cost starting point, and another list pegs it as best for solo operators testing whether tracking is worth paying for. The $29 plan is cheap, but 15 prompts is half of our workload. The four fixed engines (ChatGPT, AI Overviews, Perplexity, Copilot) are sensible, while Gemini and others cost extra. If you only want to see whether your brand appears at all, it is the lowest-friction entry.

Rankscale

Favicon of Rankscale

Rankscale

AI visibility scaling platform
View more
Screenshot of Rankscale website

Rankscale has the widest engine list of the four, 17+ on every plan, and you choose which engines to spend credits on. That flexibility is the appeal and the trap. Credits make it hard to predict your bill until you've run a month. Also note the price conflict: Fame says $17/mo yearly only, Rank Prompt says from $20/mo, and another roundup lists $99 for Pro. Check rankscale.ai/pricing directly. Agencies seem to be its target, thanks to white-label reports.

Airefs

Favicon of Airefs

Airefs

Affordable AI search monitoring tool
View more
Screenshot of Airefs website

Airefs is built for agencies: unlimited clients, prompts and reports on one plan, with 5,000 answers a month included. For a single brand with 30 prompts, that is a generous allowance. It also includes crawler visits, AI-referred visits, an MCP server and white-label PDFs. Two problems. The site's button reads "Get early access" and links to a booking page, so check whether self-serve signup exists. And G2 shows a different tier structure (Lite $24, Pro $49, Expert $83 billed annually) from the single-plan agency page. One of them is stale, or they are separate product lines. Ask before you commit.

Nimt.ai

Nimt is at $89/mo for Flex: 10,000 credits that roll over, daily tracking, up to 72 prompts, and unlimited users, projects, languages and data retention across 230 countries. Models include ChatGPT, ChatGPT Search, Bing AI Mode, Google AI Mode, AI Overviews, Gemini and Claude via API. It also includes an AI Search Agent in Slack that audits pages and produces content, plus an MCP server. It is not a budget tracker next to Rankscale at $17, but it is the only one of the four selling an agent. Its API is not in Flex. Third-party directories list older prices ($59 and $69), so ignore those. I could not find how many credits one check costs, which is the number you need to know whether 10,000 credits is plenty or tight. It starts with $45 in free credits, which makes it easy to measure that yourself.

Engine overlap: the part people skip

A fair comparison needs the same engines on every tool. Here is where the four overlap:

EngineOtterlyRankscaleAirefsNimt
ChatGPTYesYesYesYes
Google AI OverviewsYesYesYesYes
CopilotYesYesYesBing AI Mode listed
GeminiAdd-onYesYesYes
PerplexityYesYesNot listedNot listed
ClaudeAdd-onYesAdd-onYes via API

The safe shared set is ChatGPT, AI Overviews and Copilot (treating Nimt's Bing AI Mode as the closest match, which you should confirm). That makes the workload 30 x 3 x 30 = 2,700 answers a month if run daily. If a tool needs add-ons to cover those engines, add that to its price.

How to run the actual test

If you want real data instead of my arithmetic, this takes about a week of free trials and a spreadsheet.

Step 1: build the prompt set

Write 30 prompts: 10 branded ("Is [brand] good for X?"), 10 category ("best X tools for small teams"), and 10 comparison ("[brand] vs [competitor]"). Use identical wording in every tool. Do not let any tool suggest or rewrite prompts for this run.

Step 2: lock the settings

Same engines (the shared three), same country, same language, same schedule. Run daily for 7 days so each prompt gets several samples. A 2026 study of Perplexity, OpenAI search and Gemini found citation rankings are unstable across samples, so a single run per prompt proves little.

Step 3: record what each tool reports

For each tool and prompt, log whether your brand is mentioned, its position, which sources are cited, and sentiment if offered. Add a manual spot check: run 5 of the prompts yourself in the real ChatGPT and AI Overviews interfaces and compare.

Step 4: compare agreement, not scores

Each tool invents its own visibility score, so don't compare scores. Compare the raw mention yes/no per prompt-engine pair. Where the four tools disagree on the same prompt, that is the interesting finding. High disagreement means at least one tool is sampling differently or using a different access method (API versus real interface).

Step 5: normalise for engine behaviour

Citation counts differ a lot by engine. According to Promptwatch Data on average sources per response, ChatGPT cites about 5 sources per answer when web search triggers, Google AI Overviews about 10, and Perplexity almost exactly 10 every day. Copilot swung from under 2 to nearly 17 within weeks. So a citation rate pooled across engines is meaningless. Report it per engine.

Also remember that your tracked prompt is not what the engine searches. Promptwatch's ChatGPT query fanout data shows averages of roughly 1 to 2 fanout searches per response in early 2026, with query length falling from about 117 characters in December to about 53 in April. Nimt lists query fan-out in its dashboard, and it is worth checking whether the others expose it.

Which one should you pick

  • You want the cheapest entry and have 15 prompts or fewer: Otterly.AI at $29.
  • You are an agency with many clients: Airefs on volume and white-label reports, if self-serve access is confirmed. Rankscale if you want engine choice.
  • You want one engine list that goes beyond the big four: Rankscale.
  • You want an agent that acts on the gaps and don't mind $89: Nimt.ai, after burning through the $45 free credits to learn its per-check cost.
  • You need more than monitoring, such as AI crawler logs, AI traffic attribution and content that closes the gaps: none of these four is built primarily for that. Promptwatch covers that loop end to end (the Essential plan starts at $95/mo, so check promptwatch.com/pricing), and a 7-day trial exists.
Favicon of Promptwatch

Promptwatch

AI search visibility and optimization platform
View more
Screenshot of Promptwatch website

For a wider view of the category, the directory at ai-rank-tools.com lists many more trackers, and bestgeosoftware.com covers the fuller GEO platforms.

What I would verify before paying

  • Rankscale's real entry price ($17, $20, or $99 Pro).
  • Whether Airefs has self-serve signup and which of its two pricing structures is current.
  • Otterly's price for 30 prompts.
  • Nimt's credits per check, so you can turn 10,000 credits into answers.
  • Whether each tool collects from real interfaces or APIs, since the two can return different answers and citations.

Prices in this category were re-read in July and November 2026 by different publishers and already disagree. Treat any figure here, including mine, as a snapshot.

Share:

© 2026 Toolsolved · Find the best marketig tools · RSS

Toolsolved is an affiliate review site. When you click links to vendors or buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Toolsolved is a review website based on user reviews on Reddit and G2, and on publicly available information. We keep everything as up to date as possible, but pricing and features can change. Always confirm the details with the vendor before purchasing.